San Jose Raise Minimum Wage: Good or Bad?

Link to the main article: http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2012/05/23/san-jose-puts-minimum-wage-hike-on.html?s=print

  Minimum wage is often a controversial issue between the employees and employers; the employees looking for more high pay jobs and the employers unwilling to indulge in high wage expenses. This is such that most economists have argued that the relationship between minimum wage and employment is clear-cut and often leads to the destruction of jobs, while some argues that it is beneficial to the working class.

     Economically speaking, wage rate influences a number of things. It adjusts to make the quantity of labor demanded equal to the quantity supplied. Companies are responsible in considering how much labor to demand or in simpler terms, hire.  And so, with an increased minimum wage rate, the quantity demanded of labor for the firm decreases. On the other hand, the people are responsible for the supply of labor and thus with an increased minimum wage rate, the quantity supplied is increased. So with these two conflicting ideas, a change in minimum wage easily becomes a controversial issue.

     It is reported that the San Jose people supported the proposal of raising the minimum wage to $10 per hour and the main reason is to increase their income. On another perspective, the wage rate is influenced by the economy. The influence is shown when there is a rise in price levels. As more people are not able to afford a higher cost of living with their current income, they will need a higher income to cope with their expenditures. This is where the labor union comes in. Employees would go on strike and force the government to impose a regulation to the market: price floor, which is also known as the minimum.

     One setback to the raising of the minimum wage is that not everyone benefits from it. As for the companies, they tend to look for the easiest and cheapest way to earn profit. This is a common fact in the business world. So I think it does not come as a surprise that businesses would be dissatisfied with the minimum wage imposed in the labor market. As minimum wage rises, the cost of employing low skilled labor also rises. Thus, the company would be reluctant to demand more labor. This is because, as shown in the graph above, when the minimum wage rises above the equilibrium wage, the quantity of labor supplied overwhelms the quantity of labor demanded and so there is a surplus of labor. The equilibrium of the wage rate was at $8 per hour, but the government increases the minimum wage to $10 per hour. Here, the minimum wage is higher than the equilibrium of wage rate. As mentioned before, the government increases the minimum wage to keep up with the rising prices, or in broader terms, price patterns. Now, more people tend to look for work and so job search is increased. However, the equilibrium of quantity demanded of labor decreases as company is unwilling to employ more workers because of the higher wage expenses. The quantity supplied of labor is higher than the quantity demanded of labor. Hence, surplus of labor occurs.

     Although the minimum wage is increased to $10 per hour, some companies would pay workers salary below the price floor. This is beneficial to the companies to earning more profits because of lower wage expenses. However, there is a government-imposed regulation, called price floor, which makes it illegal for companies to charge below a specified level. On the other hand, confronted with the surplus of labor or in other words, competitors for jobs, the job searchers are forced to accept the terms of the companies and receive a lower income. In this particular situation, the companies and the already employed workers are the ones who benefits while the job searchers are the ones who lose. With the surplus of labor on the rise, the minimum wage is interpreted as inefficient. However, on the brighter side, unemployment rate would decrease, as more and more people are able to find jobs.

     With both perspectives on the issue of raising wage rate addressed, it is seen that minimum wage is unfair. The companies are confronted with the complications of price level patterns and surplus of labor and the discrimination inevitably comes in. Faced with the choice of choosing between the more skillful workers or the less skillful workers-and the salary is the same for both-any company would hire the former. Religion, races, and personal background may also come in the mix. Eventually, all these would lead to the big issue of unemployment. This is proved as the inefficiency of increased minimum wage and the one who suffer the most are the job searchers. Like so, minimum wage is unfair because the one who gain profit from it are the workers who are currently employed and have no need to search for a new job.

     Despite the downside of things, unemployment for low-skilled workers can be reduced. I think one approach is to raise their skills so as to increase the chance for companies to hire them. Trainings and workshops can be held for the low-wage workers to help improve their ability and increase their productivity. This makes them more valuable to the employers and thus, the demand for labor easily increases. As shown in the graph above, when labor productivity increases, so will the demand for labor so the demand curve shift to the right. This makes the equilibrium wage rate rise and employment opportunities will eventually increase.

     A raise in minimum wage have both its disadvantages and advantages. While it benefits the workers in general, the same could not be said to the job searchers or even the companies. Those people who already have jobs would only gain a higher income. For the companies, they will have to face an increase in expenses and a decrease in profits. Lastly, unless the job searchers fulfill the high expectations of the companies, most of them will not benefit from an increase in wage rate. The other downside to the minimum wage is that it does not address the core issues of low income but instead, the exploitation of newly hired workers. In short, all the minimum wage does is only to incur unemployment – its disadvantages more than its advantages.

Subsidy of sugar ,price elasticity of demand of kit kat and cadbury

Link to the main article:

http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/malaysia/article/sugar-20-sen-dearer-from-tomorrow

 

Our Prime Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak announced that the subsidy for the sugar will be cut down by Rm0.20 per kg. This means that the price of the sugar will be raise by Rm0.20 per kg. From the article, the original price of the sugar is Rm2.30 per kg, and after increase of Rm0.20, the price will be Rm2.50.

The increase in price is around 8.7%. Although there are increase in price in sugar, but the estimated quantity demanded for sugar will not decreased more than the percentage increased. This is because sugar is necessity for the consumers. From the past history based on the article, the sugar price increased 4 times. However, the quantity demanded for it did not decreased so much. Sugar as necessity, although its price increased, but buyer still have to buy it because need it in daily life. We can say that the price elasticity of demand for sugar is inelastic. This is because the percentage change in quantity demanded is less than the percentage change in price. There is one more statistic shows that the price elasticity of sugar is inelastic. In year 2011, the price of the sugar increased from Rm2.10 to Rm 2.30, it is an increase of 9.5%. However, according to FELDA Global’s sugar unit MSM Malaysia Holdings Bhd’s financial report, the sales revenue for the quarter is only slow down by 2.9 per cent. The PED of the sugar is just 0.3.

 

According to our Prime Minister, the raise of the price of the sugar is because there were too many people having diabetes.  This is also one of the evidence that the quantity demanded of sugar do not decrease significantly although the price of the sugar had been increased by 4 times. Another reason of why the quantity demanded of sugar do not decreased so much is because sugar is having less substitute’s goods. Although there are brown sugar and other substitutes in the market, but they are not generally accepted by the consumers.

 As a wrapping up, although the price of the sugar increased, but its quantity demanded will not decrease so much as it is a necessity good.

 

Price Elasticity of Demand of kit kat and cadbury

 Price elasticity of demand of kit kat chocolate refers to the extent of change in price of a product demanded by buyers in response to the change in its prices. It is measured as percentage change in quantity of a product demanded divided by percentage change in the price of the product. When the price increase from RM5 to RM6, the quantity demand decrease from 100units to 70units. The total revenue decreases from RM500 (RM5 x 100units) to RM420 (RM6 x 70units), it shows that the price is elastic.When the price of cadbury increase from RM5 to RM6, the quantity demand decreases from 100units to 90units. The total revenue increases from RM500 (RM5 x 100units) to RM540 (RM6 x 90units), it shows that the price is inelastic.

that product A kit kat is elastic; therefore the price cannot be changed indiscriminately as its quantity is relatively responsive to the price changes. While, product B cadbury is inelastic, consequently the price can change according to the firm’s will. It is because its quantity is relatively less responsive to the price changes.  Therefore, price elasticity of demand is very useful in the real life situation in helping firm build its price strategy for its product. It can assist managers to recognize how changes in price of a product will shock the total sales of the product. This insight helps the managers to determine the prices of different products that will yield maximum profit for their businesses. And managers be familiar with that when absolute value is greater than 1, the price elasticity demand is elastic. While, when absolute value is lesser than 1, the price elasticity demand is inelastic.

Price elasticity is determined by a number of factors. There are number of substitutes, time and definition of the market. As the product has more substitutes then its price elasticity of demand will be more elastic. This is because once the price of the product increase, people will try to buy other alternative products. However, if there is no substitutes for certain product, although the price of the product itself increased, people cannot switch to other alternative, then it will be more inelastic.There is a real life example of this case, the price of Cadbury decreased slightly because the ingredients can be done in Malaysia recently, and this caused the sales of the Cadbury chocolate increased.

Secondly, time is significant. When something new is entering the market, there are no substitutes in the market; consequently it will be more inelastic. However, in long term, more parallel product will enter the market, and then people have other choices and will switch to alternative once price increased.For that reason, in the early period of new market, the product will be more inelastic, but in long term the product will be more elastic.

.Lastly, market definition is important in determine the price elasticity of demand. For instance kit kat chocolates have other substitutes, for example cadbury . The price elasticity of demand for Kit Kat is elastic since it has many substitutes. If we wider the definition of the market, we changed the Kit kat to cadbury market, then it will have lesser substitutes. The price elasticity of demand will be more inelastic.

 

 

 

 

 

 

GM profit doubles as sales and prices rise

Link to the main article :

http://biz.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?sec=bus&file=/2011/8/5/business/20110805092613

The article talks about the General Motor (GM) Company. It states that although the price of the product increased but its sales still increase as well. In this article, the price of the Chevrolet Cruze increased 3 times in this year. The total price increased is $500. The price of the Chevrolet Cruze is roughly about $17000. An increase of $500 is an increase of around 3%. It can be calculated as: ($17500-$17000)/17000.Even although the price of the Chevrolet Cruze has increased, but sales still rose by 7%. According to law of demand, if the price of the good itself increased, the quantity demanded of the good will decreased, ceteris paribus. However, there are other factors which will shift the demand curve to the right, which means the price of the good itself do not increase but the demand will increase. In this case, this article is little complicated. This is because it is a mixture of increase in the price itself and also other factor shifting the demand of the good to the right. The changes in the price and demand for the Chevrolet Cruze can be explained by the graph below. I will place a number of sales for the Chevrolet Cruze as the article only stated the percentage increase.

Graph1

Image

 

Image

 

Graph 3

 Image

The 3 graphs explain on how the movement along the quantity demanded and the shift within the demand curve for Chevrolet Cruze. The 1st graph is regarding the quantity demanded is 10000 units when the price of $17000, and quantity demanded is 9500 unit when at $17500. According to the article, it is because of the earthquake-related shortages at Toyota, Honda and other competitors, therefore the customers change their taste preference and switch to alternative choice which is Chevrolet Cruze. This caused the demand curve shift to the right. Taste and preferences is one of the determinants of changes in demand. Whenever the customers change their demand for certain good, therefore the demand of the product will be either shift to the left or right .The right shift of the demand curve is presented in graph 2. In that graph, the quantity demanded for the Chevrolet Cruze is 12500 units when at the price of $17000. Lastly, General Motor increase the price to $17500, and this cause the quantity demanded move upwards to 10700 units. As a wrapping up of the 3 graphs, the demand of Chevrolet Cruze has been increased 7 % and the price increased by $500 which shown in the article.

The law of demand states that, if all other factors remain equal, the higher the price of a good, the lesser individuals will demand for that good. The amount of a good that buyers purchase at a higher price is less because as the price of a good rise up, so does the opportunity cost of buying that goods. As a result, people will obviously avoid buying a product that will force them to forgo the consumption of something else they value more. Demand, in economic terms, shows how much of a product consumers are willing to purchase, at different price points, during a certain time period. We have limited resources, and we have to decide what we’re willing and able to purchase and at which price.

A movement refers to a change along a curve. As the price of a good increased, the quantity demanded will be decreased, and then it will be happen a movement along the curve. There are few determinants will change the demand of a good except than the price of the good itself.

Firstly, it is price of substitute’s goods. For example, Product Honda is substitutes good of Product Chevrolet , when price of Product Honda increase, consumer will not demand more for the product Honda as it is expensive, consumers will switch to alternative, which is Product Chevrolet. Therefore demand for Product A will increase and its demand curve will shift to the right. This theory actually applies in our life. When we go for shopping, we discover that Jusco mall is having promotion for “Dynamo” washing powder and the price is decreased by 10%, most probably we will buy it instead of buying “Kuat Harimau” washing powder. Although the price of the “Kuat Harimau” remains constant, however because of the decreased in the price of its substitute good, then its demand decreased.

Secondly, income of the consumer will also affect the demand of the goods. For example, if the income of the consumer increase, they have more money to spend, therefore they will buy more goods. At that moment, the demand curve for the goods will shift to the right. However, not demand for the goods will increase only demand for normal good will increased. There is a real life instance for this theory, when our salary increased , we will have extra money to spend, so before increased of salary, we may only purchase car once a five years . However, after increased of salary, maybe we will buy a another car two years once. This made us to purchase more of the goods sold. Therefore the demand of the product will increased due to the raise of income.

Thirdly, expectation is also the determinant of demand. If the consumer expect the price of Product A will increased in future, then the demand curve of product A will shift to right at current time. This is because the consumers wish to purchase it before the price is increased. When the price of vehicle of Chevrolet will be increased in few days, the people will rush to the car dealers to pump to purchase before the increased of price of car take effect. For instance “ The star newspaper reported that on june 3rd 2010” that the cars showroom is crowd with people before the price of car price of Chevrolet increase.

Lastly, preference also affect demand, If consumer are look important at vehicle product, then demand for the particular product will shift to the right. Supply relates to the producer’s desire to make a profit. A supply schedule shows the amount of product that suppliers are willing, able to produce and make available to the market at specific price points during a certain time period. In short, it shows us the quantities that suppliers are willing to offer at various prices. This happens because suppliers tend to have different costs of production. At a lower price, only the most efficient producers can make a profit, so only they produce. At a higher price, even high cost producers can make a profit as everyone produces. This is happening commonly in our life now days. Try to come across at the vehicle Chevrolet Cobalt, before this car was launched the price of the previous addition of Chevrolet is not added than Rm157127 per unit. However, when the new Chevrolet cobalt arrived, populace feel that the vehicle is potentially to buy, therefore more and more people demand for the particular vehicle and this caused the price to be increased. In this circumstance the car dealers felt that they may put on more profit if they sell off their vehicles; consequently they are selling their vehicles, which means the supply of the vehicle increased due to raise in price.

There are also few determinants of changes in supply. Price of related good will affects supply. For instance, “ the Chevrolet company” factory can produce GM cars and trucks at same time, if the price of car is increased, then the factory will choose to produce trucks as it gives high profit, then the supply curve will shift to right. Secondly, if the price of input changes, it will also shift the supply curve. For example, if car price raise, the cost of production increased, the firm will produce less although the price of the product remains the same. This shifts the supply curve to left.

Lastly, the advancement in technology also will affect supply. For exemplar, if there is a new technology being introduced and it will lead to increase in productivity, consequently the supply will increased and supply curve shift to the right. In 7 Sept 2012, Chevrolet developed a new technology to weld together steel and aluminum and achieve world’s first application to the frame of a mass production vehicle, with this new technology invented, the production of Chevrolet’s vehicle will surely increased.

 

Fuel choices, food crisis and finger pointing

Link to the main article: http://www.merid.org/Content/News_Services/Food_Security_and_AgBiotech_News/Articles/2008/04/18/Fuel_Choices_Food_Crises_and_FingerPointing.aspx

Based on this article, merig.org on 18 April 2008, it states that U.S promotes ethanol and similar fuels, politician from poor country go against the policies in the U.S because these fuels increases food prices and some of them insisted on reanalysis of biofuel policies by the government policies of U.S. Many specialists argue that government mandates for biofuel is unadvisable, agreeing that the diversion of corn into fuel production causes higher prices. Higher demand for food is due to drought and rapid economic growth. (FAO) claims that if authority’s policies and biofuel production carries on, an increase of food cost from 10 to 15 percent is possible.

In my opinion, I totally disagree with the government policies in U.S because the soil used to grow corn and grains will become exhausted of minerals and nutrients due to overused. Additional energy needed to transport causes a negative impact on the energy produced by the ethanol. To me, corn based ethanol is profitable when exports to other countries such as Brazil. Although USA major competitor, Brazil produces sugar based ethanol which indirectly competes with USA, but in 2010, the bad weather in Brazil and India, two major sugar producing countries cause decrease in supply of sugar in Brazil. Increased in global demand increased the price of sugar. These two countries are the world’s largest sugar cane producers. The decreased in sugar supply causes Brazilian producer to produce more for sugar and less for ethanol. Thus, Brazil’s sugar-based ethanol supply is affected by increased in sugar price, it reduces its exports.  In the mean time, increase in consumer’s income causes demand of Brazil’s ethanol to increase. This shows income elastic and it’s a normal good. The decrease in exports of Brazil ethanol causes Brazilians to import more from USA.

Biofuel and food compete to utilize the same resources to produce ethanol which is made from corn. In 2007, Congress mandated a fivefold increase in use of biofuels. Due to this, farmers increases corn production. The increase in demand for corn increases the corn production and causes movement along PPF (production possibility frontier). Opportunity cost increases as moving along the PPF. Due to drought in South America, amount of corn produced does not change even though more land is used for corn production. The drought causes decrease in crop yield and the PPF curves inward. Higher opportunity cost causes cost of biofuel and food to increase. The increase in opportunity cost can be shown by the movement along PPF and inward rotation of PPF.  It is an inconsiderate movement of government policy in U.S because they do not think about the poor people in the rest of the world.

I think that corn production causes environmental impact due to increase nutrient pollution in water ways. Based on a report, Gulf of Mexico is the third largest dead zone due to nutrient pollution causes by corn production. Fertilizing corn and waste product from ethanol production, called swill is extremely poison to aquatic life. Government should enforce laws such as each factory are required to pay each unit of pollution it causes to the environment and use resources to collect data regarding nutrient pollution and fees charged towards factories from time to time. Besides, government should provide information about nutrient runoffs to public to increase awareness on how serious nutrient runoffs to the environment. People will become more aware, knowledgeable and indirectly decrease the amount of nutrient pollution.

Ethanol and gasoline are both strongly related. Ethanol is blended and mixes with gasoline to produce fuel. In 1970, the demand for gasoline is at the peak, due to this, the price increases. Government sets a price ceiling on gasoline to enable more people to afford it by limiting the price of gasoline. Thus, shortage occurs. Due to decrease in price, more quantity demanded than quantity supplied. Inefficiency occurs and creates a dead weight lost due to marginal benefit exceeds marginal cost. The shortage must be allocated among the demanders. The seller and buyers of gasoline increased activity to get the best price for gasoline and incurs an opportunity cost which is the time spent on searching which ended up higher than the price of gasoline without price ceiling. A black market occurs when the price sells exceeds price ceiling.

Recently, the demand of gasoline declines each year after 2007. This is due to government mandates on ethanol, increased efficiency of vehicles from ethanol and ethanol blending limit. It is the limit of ethanol blended to gasoline. I disagree with the government policy in USA in having subsidies in ethanol because although it promotes biofuel for production, thus, less depends on imported oil, but ended up environmental pollution far worse than gasoline. Besides, it shows that not enough acres available in the USA to grow corn to make the ethanol needed to power the vehicle. Due to subsidy, it decreases prices of product. Domestic taxpayer suffers the most as they pay the full cost. A corn farmer increases production of corn due to increase in demand.  Thus, leads to increase global price food. To overcome this problem, U.S. Department of Agriculture states that the Obama administration will implement a large sum of money to increase the biofuels production next generation. Companies will offer new biofuel projects on other plants, but not corn, and the government will match their investment. The Obama administration is planning to avoid using corn based ethanol to make fuel and relies more on USA energy independence. Apart from working up biofuel plants, the money used to fund existing corn-based plants is provided.

Rent Ceiling in New York City

Link to the main article: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/04/24/us/supreme-court-declines-to-hear-rent-control-challenge.html?_r=3

                A rent ceiling happens when the government sets the price under the equilibrium price. The rent ceiling law is imposed at about 200 cities in the United States, including New York City, Boston, and San Francisco and most of the country in Asia also has their rent ceiling imposed since early 2000. The purpose of rent ceiling is helping the poor to be able to afford the houses and homeless people. Government also try their best to eliminate the abandon houses by impose rent ceiling. It will help low income people to afford those abandon houses and also help the owners of the abandon houses to overcome their losses. ‘The Global Property Guide’ states that the rent ceiling was imposed by the government because it can help the nations avoid from high rents but it actually brings inefficiency.

            In New York City, they have their rent ceiling since 1947. According to Harmons’ lawsuit, it states that the rent ceiling price for New York City is around $1000 in 2008 which is 60% below the market price. When the rent ceiling is set below the equilibrium price, it actually causes shortage. Rent ceiling leads to decrease in supply by the landlords and the rental units will be scarce when rent ceiling is imposed. It can be proven by the graph below as it shows the shortage occurs when rent ceiling in New York City is imposed.
Image
For example, the equilibrium price for rent is at $1600 per month but the government sets price ceiling at $1000, the landlords cannot set above $1000 as it is illegal region and it must be below the equilibrium price. In this situation, the landlords are not willing to rent their houses for the consumers because the price is lower than the equilibrium price which can brings loss to them. The quantity supplied will decrease from 80 thousands units to 60 thousands units. So, the supply of rental units will be in scarce. On the other hand, the consumer will highly demand on the house rents when the price is lower than the equilibrium price. The quantity demanded is higher than the quantity supplied. Therefore, a shortage will occur there. Rent ceiling also discouraged the landlords to maintain the quality of their rental units. When the quantity demand is high, the suppliers would try their best to reduce the cost of maintenance or even no maintenance so that they would not spend money on the maintenance because the price is set below the equilibrium rent to avoid loss profit.
Image
                The graph above shows the inefficiency of rent ceiling. The search activity will increase when rent ceiling is imposed. Search activity defines the time spent to search people to do business for the landlords and the time spent to search rental houses for the nations. When rent ceiling is imposed, renters will spend a lot of time to search on the newspaper or the internet for various prices and opportunity cost will occur. The opportunity cost included the price of the house rents and also the time spent on search. Search activity is expensive because it takes up a lot of costs higher than without rent ceiling. For example, the renters will end up used a lot of costs on petrol or other resources and spend a lot of time on searching because of the limited availability of houses. As for the landlords, they will spend a lot of time to search for their customers and money on the maintenance fees because they cannot find a customer who can pay for the price which they can satisfy. Thus, search activity increased for the renters and landlords when there is a rent ceiling.

            Rent ceiling also creates black market as the landlords will find a way to go against the rent ceiling. Black market is an illegal transaction between renters and tenants which go beyond the legal limit price set by the governments. When the rent ceiling is imposed, the availability of rental units will be limit because the landlords are not willing to rent their houses. However, some of the renters will be desperate to rent the houses and the landlords will take this opportunity to offer in a high price which against the rent ceiling. Due to desperation, some of the renters are willing to pay at the price that offered by the landlords. For example, the renters are willing to pay $ 2,800 per month which offered by the landlords even though the legal price is only at $ 1,000 per month because rent ceiling causes limited availability of rental units.  From this, there will be reduction consumer surplus and producer surplus occur. Consumer surplus is the benefit received more than the price they paid for it. For example, the renters who involved in black market do not have to spend a lot of time searching and other resources like petrol expenses to search for a house. Producer surplus is the amount received more than the equilibrium price or the cost of production. For example, the legal rent price is at $1000 but some of the renters are willing to pay $2,800 for the rent and it is higher than the equilibrium price. Thus, the landlords will gain extra profit. Deadweight loss will also occur because the quantity of housing supplied is less than the equilibrium quantity. The deadweight loss is loss to the society because rent ceiling causes shortage which makes the nations unable to rent a house.
 
            In conclusion, rent ceiling only benefits the families which have higher income that already lived in a city for a long time. It is because they are able to pay at a higher price which can satisfy the landlords. The newcomers or poor nation will not able to rent any houses as the landlords are not willing to supply the rental units when the rent control is imposed under the equilibrium price. Not only that, the landlords will make a loss when the price is under the equilibrium price because they need to spend a long time to find a customer who can pay higher price which can satisfy them. This causes the renters and landlords to have difficulties. To summarize the whole thing, the rent ceiling creates shortage, increased of search activity and black market which does not benefit the society. Government should do something to overcome the inefficiencies of rent ceiling to avoid unfairness in the society.

California’s Fuel Price Rises

Link to the main article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-19853740

     The price of fuel rising has always been a dreaded news for every consumers, and in this case, the Californians. According to BBC news, the increase in fuel prices was caused by a shortage of fuel in a particular refinery and leads to the closing down of some businesses. In economic terms, a price hike will likely mean a decrease in quantity demanded, an increase in quantity supplied and inflation, all of which would eventually slow the economy.

     The law of demand states that as price of a good increase, the quantity demanded decreases, with other things remaining unchanged. This can be applied to the fuel price in California. One of the causes for this concept is the substitution effect. With such a high increase in fuel price, consumers are bound to feel unsatisfied and find other substitutions for fuel. For instance, consumers will start using public transportations, walk or cycle to their destination. To them, these would be cheaper. This indicates that the opportunity cost of fuel has increase. Thus, as people starts to look for other alternatives, the quantity demanded of fuel would eventually decrease. On the other hand, income effect is another reason for a decrease in quantity demanded. With an unchanged income and the unreasonably expensive fuel, a majority of consumers would not be able to afford goods that they have always bought . As a result, consumers are forced to reduce the quantity demanded of fuel to be able to maintain other expenses. In this instance, with the budget that results from cheaper transportation fees, people will use more of public transportation. Hence, the quantity of public transportation demanded increases because of income effect and also substitution effect. Therefore, independent petrol stations are forced to seek solution to cope with the price hike and loss of customers. As reported in BBC news, some business have “closed down their pumps rather than cut into profit margins”.

     In my opinion, the substitution effect would be the greater of the two in the United States. In a First World country like the States, public transit is not a hassle. With an increased fuel prices, coupled with the advanced technology of public transportation, there would inevitably be a resultant increase in public transit expenditures. It is evident that people would flock to use the buses, monorail and subway during the peak hours – working and lunch hours – because of cheaper transit fees. If the price remains permanently high, there will be a reduction in the car fleet, mostly of heavy vehicles, with fuel consumption decreasing. Another alternative to private transport would be using energy-efficient cars like hybrid vehicles. This also indicates an increase in fuel efficiency, due to an increased use of more fuel-efficient vehicles, reduction in private transport demand, and a decrease in congestion level.

     Besides the law of demand, the law of supply is also in the works. The law states that  as the price of a good increases, the quantity supplied increases, with other things remaining unchanged. In short, when the price of fuel increases, a large quantity of fuel that producers are willing to supply increases. Thus, producing more fuel and earning revenue from that will bring the profit of a fuel company up.

     Having said these, fuel is very significant in our daily lives. It generates our cars, trucks, electricity, and machines in the industries. With the price of oil increasing, transportation cost, utility cost, and almost everything will rise. Thus, with the price levels increasing, inflation occurs. However, the increasing of the fuel price is temporary as it is just to adapt to the shortage of oil. This can be reasoned with the concept of price adjustments. As reported in the article, a power outage, which occurs in a Californian refinery, has the supply of fuel cut, therefore causing a shortage. The graph above shows that shortage pushes the price up and toward its equilibrium price. However, the shortage would be reduced because the quantity demanded is reduced and the quantity supplied is increased by the rising price. When the shortage is gone, the price will stop increasing and instead falls back to its equilibrium price.

     The other reason that this issue would be temporary is the environment that we live in. The situation is such that we not only have a limited amount of businesses that sell fuel in an area. This environment is such that the businesses cannot afford to incur higher fuel prices for long and lose their customers because of other competitors in the area. If the price for fuel were higher in a fuel station than the other, consumer would just buy the cheaper one. Therefore, the price level will fall back to normal given an amount of time. Again, the substitution effect is recurring. In this instance, the fuel has an elastic demand.

     Another concept that can be exemplified is the elasticity of demand-closeness of substitutes and time elapsed since price change. In the States, fuel has a few close substitutes: public transportations, hybrid vehicles or even carpooling. The thing is, only if the prices are inexorably high – and stay for a long time – would high prices actually have permanent effect on consumer behavior, for example, a natural disaster occurring. In my opinion, the bottom line is that people will take any transportation just to get to work. In the case of workers transporting goods, though they are not able to use public transit, they can afford higher price fuel temporarily. In this case, the demand of fuel is elastic. The second factor that influences the elasticity of demand is the time period after a price change. The longer the fuel has to sustain without losing its value, or the longer the consumers have to adapt to a price change, the more elastic is the demand for fuel. Although the price of fuel has increased, consumers will still maintain the quantities of gasoline that they bought. This again proves that fuel has an elastic demand. On the other hand, as it is shown that the price hike is only temporary, the elasticity of demand for fuel will not undergo a big increase and remain unchanged. In addition, the reaction of quantity supplied to the price change when only some adjustments to production can be made is called short-run supply. To cope with the shortage of fuel in California, the industries just have to expand their work force and labor overtime. Hence, adjustments like these can be made in the short-run to increase production.

     Having proven that fuel is the lifeblood to our society, a temporary change in price would not result in a significant alteration to the economy. In short, a price hike can only invoke such a change that the quantity demanded is decreased, quantity supplied is increased and substitution and income effect are more recurring.

Congestion pricing in london

Link to the main article: http://www.lincolninst.edu/pubs/2041_Congestion-Pricing-An-Overview-of-Experience-and-Impact

Based on this article, lincolninst.edu on May 2011, congestion pricing have indeed control travel behavior, increases speed and decreases in traffic jams. Public transportation has replaced car pools between people. Operating expenses and costs of enhancement of public transport requires large amount of money, but congestion tolls have covered the expenses. No proof shown that shops in the charging area been badly affected. Due to traffic reduction, pollution has sharply been reduced. In 1996, a study shows that employment in central London sharply increased but decreases in inner and outer London due to congestion pricing. Besides, the advantage of congestion pricing is there is higher income household in that area. Change in price of travelling to city centre causes more business activities to occur. Bhatt states that reduction in vehicles emissions, more funds for transportation investment are due to congestion pricing.

In my opinion, despite lesser traffic jam, more revenue to fund transport improvement , evasion increases as more people uses bad ideas such as fake car plates to avoid paying. To overcome this problem, people are required to register their car plates before entering a particular place, many cameras are installed, captured and recorded in a database. This database has every details of each people’s movement. Although it helps detects people avoid paying congestion price, but cameras invades people’s privacy and in some occasion, people are wrongly ticketed. Furthermore, the income of lower class people will decrease significantly because it serves as a burden to them. Thus, this gives the largest impact when they require driving to work every day and sometimes during off-hours with congestion pricing unavoidable. It also causes unfairness because some residents staying at the particular area and handicapped people have discount on paying congestion pricing. The most important is survival rates from cardiac arrests rises due to reduction in traffic jams. Transit service is crowded during peak hours, although bus service improves and revenue is used to upgrade the system but it is still unreliable. This is because a transit system might not guarantee a handicapped person to reach their destination on time. Thus, the possibility for them to lose their job is high.

            Based on the graph above, due to congestion pricing, people will switch to public transport; the demand curve (AB section) is willing to pay a very high transport fare. This helps to cover their basic marginal cost and capital cost. However, setting a price at C will lose profit shown at triangle ABC because some people are willing to pay more (marginal benefit). At A, operator will lose profit above the marginal cost but below A. Transport operator is the one who sets the transport price. At triangle BYZ, transport operator loses some profit which some passengers that are willing to pay at above the marginal cost but not decided to pay at C price.

 Congestion pricing in shopping area causes the demand of goods to fall because people are not willing to pay congestion pricing so they will seldom drive to that area.  If the demand of goods is inelastic, a slight increase in congestion price will have small effect on reducing demand but if the demand of goods is elastic, higher price congestion pricing will cause the demand to sharply reduce in shopping areas. For low income people, it is a demand elastic as a slight increase in congestion price cause low income people to switch to bus service. The car sales will be affected as more people switch to public transport to avoid congestion pricing. Overtime the congestion charge may become more effective. In a longer run, people have time to buy a bike; shops may relocate outside the congestion charge.

As for me, I don’t agree with government policy in London. Despite congestion pricing reduces pollution because more people uses public transport, so less car, less emissions of gas but it increases pollution in an indirect way, people would travel a further distance to avoid congestion pricing. Thus, the longer distance it travelled, the more gases the vehicles discharged. In addition, the opportunity cost of government using large amount of money to buy sophisticated technology to track people who don’t pay tax is government can use the excess money on enhancement of transport running costs and improves security by installing CCTV to ensure the safety of citizens.

Besides, I think government in London should implement the congestion pricing that depends on factors such as distance travelled by vehicle in the pricing area and type of vehicles rather than fixed costs of pricing for all vehicles.  This shows a more precise cost imposed on driving. Although fixed price for all vehicles is easier to implement and understand, but it does not motivate people to minimize driving. Installing cameras in congestion area indeed easily detect people, who avoid paying taxes, but sometimes Malaysia’s congestion problem is serious during peak hours so government should build bridges or underground tunnels to smooth the jams.

 

Some people still prefer to drive car because it is more convenient to go any places. In 2007, the demand for Honda car in London increases because it is environmental friendly, so government encourage user by having tax reduction. Besides, it has the ability to detect traffic jams. Honda increases supply to meet rising demand of consumers.

The negative externalities are damage on roads due to frequently crossing by vehicles and pollution. By having congestion pricing, less people drives car and takes public transport, means less car leads to less wear and tear on the road. Thus, road maintenance cost will be decreased. Cars becoming more fuel efficient help to reduce pollution. Besides, cost to employee loses job because the employer gets angry with their lack of productivity due to using public transport every day.  Government should think twice before implementing a law to ensure citizens have the maximum benefit.

Purpose of 2013 Budget: It Brings Advantages and Inefficiencies

Link to the main article: http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?sec=budget&file=/2012/9/29/budget/12102391

                Government is very important in every country. The role of the government is to protect the nations and provide a better country for the nations. Recently, 2013 budget was tabled by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak on 28 September 2012.  The 2013 budget is said to benefit all the nations in Malaysia. The purpose of 2013 budget was tabled is to improve quality of life, ensure security of the society and provide financial assistance for the Education Ministry but some of the plans in 2013 budget bring disadvantages too.

            One of the main purposes of Budget 2013 focus is to improve nation’s quality of life by “boosting investment activities; intensifying innovation and increasing productivity; advancing education and training; enhancing the rakyat’s quality of life and strengthening the achievements of public service”. The Budget 2013 benefits most of the sectors to ensure the quality of life. The sectors will get the budget and they can use it in their productivity so that the nations can afford. When the productivity is increase, the price will drop and the nations can afford it at a lower price. For example, the government will provide funds and also allocations for new initiatives to the housing programmes to increase the supply of affordable houses. When the quantity supplied increases, the price will automatically decrease which will definitely benefit to those low income citizens. Even though it does bring benefits to the society but if the quantity supplied is too many; it will causes oversupply and it will creates abandon houses in the society if the quantity demand is not high.

            Budget 2013 also improves the quality of life by providing better public transport and connectivity of locations. The public transport provided by the government is a public good. A public good is everyone can get benefit from it and no one will be excluded from its benefit. It would benefits everyone but it also has disadvantage. The disadvantage is the free-rider problem. A free rider is a person who enjoys the benefits from the public goods without paying any money to contribute the costs. Free-rider problem occurs because government provide an inefficiency small quantity of a public good. Thus, the marginal social benefit will be higher than the marginal social cost and it causes deadweight loss. Government should at least collect some taxes from them in order to reduce the deadweight loss.

            According to Star, government has spent RM 591mil to reduce the crime rate in Malaysia under Budget 2013. From the RM 591 mil, RM 70 mil will be used for the 10,000 Police Volunteers Reserve, RM 20mil for the 1,000 motorcycles, 496 units of CCTV cameras in urban areas, and RM 90mil for the People’s Volunteer Corp. The purpose on spending budgets on these is to reduce the crime rate in Malaysia. Recently, there is a lot of crime cases happened in Malaysia. It is due to lack of security. The increase of Police Volunteers Reserve and People’s Volunteer Corp would definitely help the police in crime cases. The 1,000 motorcycles would help to improve the security of housing areas by patrolling. The police would patrol in the housing areas day and night to prevent crime cases happen. It provides social benefits to the citizen. Datuk Bandar Datuk Roshidi Hashim said that 24 units of CCTV cameras installed in Ipoh last year have reduced the crime rate. With the installation for 496 units of CCTV cameras in urban areas for 2013 definitely will reduce the crime rates because police would trace down the criminals. It maximizes the satisfaction of the society but the quantity supplied of CCTV is too few as it only for urban areas and not for other areas. The quantity supplied is lower than the quantity demanded, thus it causes underproduction. Government should think of an efficient way to overcome the inefficient small quantity of the CCTV. Government should also focus on the other areas so that everyone receives the same social benefit.

            In Budget 2013, government also provide financial assistance for the Education Ministry. Government provide RM3.7bil for training students in technical and vocational fields. Nowadays, there is oversupply of graduate students who does not have basic skills and most of them are rejected by the company which causes the unemployment rate to be increased. Thus, government provides fund for them to receive some trainings to reduce the unemployment. When the graduate students are more experience in working field, the quantity demanded by the companies will increase. This can help to decrease the unemployment rate which can benefits the society. Not only that, it also helps the economy of the country when there are more professional people in the country. It can benefit the country and avoid slow development of the economy.

             Other than that, government also spend RM1bil to upgrade the schools and RM 600mil for five research universities. This plan can benefit the low income people as it satisfies their needs. The free-rider problem also exists when government involved in public school system. The low income people who have more children in public schools and pay lower property taxes free ride on others who are higher income with fewer children in public schools and pay higher property taxes. The higher income enjoys benefit from education and fewer crime rates when the society is more educated. Hence, the marginal social benefit is higher than the marginal social cost. Government should also provide funds to the private universities to allow all the students in private universities gain benefits from it.

            In conclusion, Budget 2013 will benefit and also inefficient to all the nations in term of quality of life, security of society and financial assistance. All the plans bring advantage and disadvantages. Government should be more alert on not only on the advantages of the plans, but also disadvantages of the plans so that they can overcome the problems. Government should make efficient plans which produce maximum benefits to the society without any inefficiency. Government also should not focus only on low income people but also high income people because it would bring unfairness if they only focus on low income people. All the plans should benefit all people from the society.